The Truth About the Schlotzsky's 'Secret Menu'
Schlotzsky's does not publish an official secret menu. What circulates online as a 'secret menu' is really a set of ordering hacks — custom combinations and tweaks that the kitchen can usually make because the ingredients are already on hand. Nothing here is a hidden item the chain is keeping from you; these are just smart ways to reorder from the regular menu.
Because every Schlotzsky's is franchise-operated, whether a particular customization works depends on the location and how busy they are. Be friendly, be specific, and be prepared to pay for extra toppings. The worst that happens is they say no.
Popular Schlotzsky's Ordering Hacks
Try these custom builds the next time you order. Each one uses standard ingredients and can be requested at most locations.
Sandwich & Pizza Hacks
- The Double Original: Ask for extra ham, salami and cheese on The Original for a much heartier sandwich.
- No-Bun Original: Request your sandwich filling as a salad-style bowl without the bread — popular with low-carb diners.
- Extra Toasty: Ask for your sandwich to run through the oven twice for a crispier crust and hotter cheese.
- Half-and-Half Pizza: Request two different toppings on each half of a whole pizza (availability varies).
- Sauce on the Side: Get the signature sauce and any dressing in a cup so you control how much goes on.
Sides & Drink Hacks
- Chip Crunch: Ask for a handful of kettle chips inside your sandwich for added texture.
- Soup & Half Combo: Pair a cup of soup with a half sandwich for a lighter, balanced lunch.
- Extra Olives: The Original already includes black olives — ask for extra at little or no cost.
- Free Hot Sauce: Schlotzsky's bottles its own Original Hot Sauce; ask for packets on the side.
How to Order Like a Regular
The key to a successful custom order is clarity. Name the base item first, then list each change one at a time: 'The Original, no olives, extra cheddar, sauce on the side.' Speak up about allergies before the order is placed. And remember that big changes may add to the price — a 'free' secret menu does not mean free ingredients.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Schlotzsky's have a real secret menu?
No official secret menu exists. The 'secret' items people discuss are customizations of regular menu items using ingredients the kitchen already has.
Will they honor custom orders at every location?
Not always. Since stores are franchised, staffing and ingredient availability vary. Simple swaps usually work; elaborate builds may not.
Do secret menu hacks cost extra?
Often yes. Extra meat, cheese or toppings normally carry an upcharge. Removing items or requesting sauce on the side is usually free.
Is the 'Double Original' an official item?
No. It is a nickname for ordering The Original with extra meat and cheese. You will need to spell out the changes when you order.